Distinct from peerages, altered by legislation in 2004, and often described with terminology that is now out of date. What the law and the institutional sources actually say.
Last reviewed October 2026 · Sourced from primary legislation and the Court of the Lord Lyon
Baronage of Scotland Association · Frequently Asked QuestionsRead first · before Paper 1
Scottish Baronies, Explained
Distinct from peerages, altered by legislation in 2004, and often described with terminology that is now out of date. What the law and the institutional sources actually say.
Last reviewed October 2026 · www.baronage.com/scottish-baronies-explained/
Where does a Scottish baron rank?New
The Noblesse of Scotlandin order of precedenceIn English usage all below a peer are commoners; but UK law includes Scots law.
BaronsBarons and barons of higher dignities in the baronage of Scotland
Titled nobility; noblemen; “minor barons”; before 1943 sometimes incorrectly untitled nobility, and before 2004 feudal barons (both terms are now defunct)
BaronsBarons and barons of higher dignities in the baronage of Scotland
Scots lawTitled nobility; noblemen; “minor barons”; before 1943 sometimes incorrectly untitled nobility, and before 2004 feudal barons (both terms are now defunct)
“Their precedence was thus after Knights and before Esquires.”Innes of Learney, 1945
In 1945 the Lyon Court declared a Scottish baron “of rank equivalent to that denominated Hoch Adel”, the Continent’s high nobility.
In Scotland, greater or lesser, all are noble: “though all these be not Peers of Parliament, yet they are all Peers to one another” (Mackenzie, 1680). Rank decided who could fight or marry whom, yet a baron, even a gentleman as untitled nobility, counted as a duke’s peer: he could challenge him to a duel and marry his daughter.
Above the shield
“The rank of a Peer is shown by the Coronet.”Court of the Lord Lyon
DukeEight strawberry leaves
MarquisFour leaves, four pearls
EarlEight pearls on points, eight leaves
ViscountSixteen pearls
Lord of ParliamentSix pearls
Each drawing shows the front of the coronet; the numbers count all the way round.
Baron: the chapeau
A red cap turned up with ermine.
1650The Baron of Roslin is found in his vault lying in his armour, with a red velvet cap on his head.
1835The Lyon Court allows the heir of the barons of Dolphinton a cap “as being indicative of his descent from the ancient barons of Dolphington”.
1934The Lord Lyon “found the claim established, and awarded the chapeau” to the Baron of Esslemont.
1625The King’s patents set baronets before knights, barons, esquires and gentlemen.
1672The Lyon Register enters baronets, knights and barons together, ahead of the gentlemen.
Peers: Treaty of Union, art. XXIII ↗ (“Peers of Scotland”); Dictionary of the Older Scottish Tongue, “Pere” n.1, sense 5 ↗ (“in Scotland, a member of the titled nobility”). The greater barons: “the greater barons and the lesser barons, the former acquiring such titles as Duke or Earl”, Lord Clyde in Spencer-Thomas of Buquhollie v Newell 1992 SLT 973 ↗; Sir George Mackenzie, Works, vol. ii (1716), p. 550 ↗ (“Now the Lords are called the great Barons, and the rest are called small Barons in the 101 Act, 7 Parl. James I. and ever since”), also p. 534 ↗ and p. 545 ↗ (“With us all are called Barons who hold their Lands of the King in libera baronia”, that is, in free barony).
Baronets: the patents create the hereditary state, degree, dignity, name, order, title and style of baronet (Mackenzie, Works, vol. ii, p. 547 ↗). Baronets of Nova Scotia, the baronetage of Scotland: Charles I’s letter of 17 November 1629 speaks of “the Baronets of that our ancient Kingdom” (Mackenzie, Works, vol. ii, p. 549 ↗); “The relative position in Scotland of baronets of Nova Scotia was fixed by their charters of creation and by Act of Parliament” (Stair Memorial Encyclopaedia, vol. 16 (1995), “Precedence”, para. 2019 ↗), the Act being that of 1633 (RPS 1633/6/43 ↗). See How the baronets pleaded the barons’ nobility.
Knights and barons as noblemen: Act of 10 December 1540, “every noble man, such as an earl, lord, knight and baron”, in the modern English of the Records of the Parliaments of Scotland, 1540/12/30 ↗. Knights of the Thistle and knights bachelor: both stand in the order of precedence “recognised by the Lyon King of Arms”, J. H. Stevenson, “Precedence”, in Green’s Encyclopaedia of the Law of Scotland, vol. IX (1898), p. 387 ↗; the knights bachelor are the “milites aurati”, gilded knights, of the baronets’ patents of 1625 (note 20).
Barons: “…the nobility, earls, lords and barons…”, Parliament of Scotland, 1592 (RPS 1592/4/72 ↗, modern English; the Act of 1540 is in note 7); a barony does “ennoble” (Mackenzie, Works, vol. ii, p. 583 ↗); “recognised as a ‘titled nobility’”, Lyon Court interlocutor of 26 February 1943, printed by Innes of Learney, PSAS 79, p. 143 n. 3 ↗; “of the rank of minor barons or untitled nobility of Scotland”, Lyon Court birthbrief of March 1930: see Untitled in 1930, titled in 1943 and Barons in the Gazette. “Feudal barons” until feudal tenure ended on 28 November 2004 under the Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000 ↗, whose s. 63 keeps the dignity of baron and “any quality or precedence associated with” it.
Esquires, chiefs, lairds and gentlemen: the Lyon Court’s grant of 1984 in note 1 was to an armiger without a title. See Lairds, lords and barons.
The Lyon Court’s declaration in the matriculation of Wauchope of Niddrie, 19 April 1945 (Lord Lyon Sir Francis Grant), Lyon Register vol. xxxv, p. 31, printed by Innes of Learney, PSAS 79 (1944–45), p. 160 ↗: the petitioner “is of Baronial Race, and of rank equivalent to that denominated Hoch Adel, and equivalent to the Chiefs of Baronial Houses, upon the Continent of Europe”. The same paper, p. 146: “where a Feudal Baronage still exists as a constitutional ‘Order’, this—following the Continental usage—is officially recognised as Hoch-adel”.
Sir George Mackenzie on precedency (1680), in his Works, vol. ii (1716), p. 534 ↗: “Nobility is divided with us, as in England, into nobiles majores & minores, the greater and the lesser Nobility. Under the greater are comprehended all such as are Lords of Parliament, under the lesser are comprehended Knights and Gentlemen; and though all these be not Peers of Parliament, yet they are all Peers to one another”; “a Nobleman is obliged to accept of a Challenge from a Gentleman as his Peer, where Duels are lawful”, and, in the next sentence, “Under the Word Baron all our Nobility are comprehended, as is clear by the 81 Act, Parl. 14. James II.” He goes on: the first Parliament of James V was held, in the words of its Latin heading, by the guardian of the King and kingdom with the prelates, barons and commissioners of the burghs, while that of Robert I was held with the bishops, abbots, priors, earls, barons and other great men, which shows that there were great men below the barons (“magnates infra barones”). Also on that page: “a Gentleman may be offered to a Duke’s Daughter whose Ward and Marriage falls to the King, as has been often decided, nor can that Match be refused upon the account of Inequality”. Rank decided who could fight whom: at Carberry Hill on 15 June 1567 Bothwell refused the Laird of Tullibardine’s challenge, “saying, That he was not a Peer of the Kingdom, as he was” (John Knox, History of the Reformation, book V, in D. Laing (ed.), The Works of John Knox, vol. ii (1848), p. 561 ↗). The baron as a landed gentleman: “our Lairds or landed Gentlemen” (Mackenzie, Works, vol. ii, p. 550 ↗).
The petition of Ainslie of Pilton, “heir and representative of the Feudal Barons of Dolphinton”, and the Lyon Court’s interlocutor of 28 November 1835: Innes of Learney, PSAS 79 (1944–45), p. 153 ↗.
The patent of Sir Robert Gordon, the first baronet, 28 May 1625, printed in F. W. Pixley, A History of the Baronetage (1900), p. 83 ↗; in Sir George Mackenzie’s English of 1680, the baronet goes “before all Knights, called equites aurati, all lesser Barons, commonly called Lairds, and before all other Gentlemen” (“Of Precedency”, in his Works, vol. ii (1716), p. 547 ↗); Innes of Learney, PSAS 79 (1944–45), p. 113 ↗.
Yes. Historically, barons were untitled nobility as baron was a description not a title, the first hereditary titles were lords and earls. The Declaration of Arbroath of 1320 shows the practice: of the thirty-nine nobles named at its head — eight earls and thirty-one barons — only the earls and two lords are titled, “Jacobus Dominus de Duglas” and “Dauid Dominus de Brechyn”, the other barons appearing by name alone; and the descent of those lordships shows the lord’s title already running as a hereditary rank. Whether “baron” was a name of dignity or only a description of a man’s tenure was argued for centuries: Mackenzie records in 1680 that the old barons, “especially where they are Chiefs of Clans”, refused to yield precedence to baronets although “the other pretend that a Baron is no Name of Dignity”. The 1672 Act let only peers and bishops sign by their titles; barons signed by name, “of” their lands. In 1943 the Court of the Lord Lyon found and declared that the minor barons “are, and have been” recognised as a “titled nobility” (see The Lord Lyon’s Case for the Baronage).
The record on the side of “title” is long. A document of 1382 states that Baronia est nomen dignitatis et importat judicaturam — barony is a name of dignity and imports jurisdiction. The Crown charter of 1590 erecting Spynie into a free barony conferred the “title, honour, rank and status of a free baron”. The Great Seal records in 1589: Colville was to be called baron of Culross, and Keith was given the title and honour of baron of Delny. The sheriff-court suit-rolls entered a baron as “A, Baro de B” exactly as an earl was entered “A, Comes de B”. Mary Queen of Scots wrote to “Our traist friend the barroun of Kylrawak”, and Lord Lyon Erskine of Cambo styled himself “Baro de Cambo”. Against it stood Mackenzie’s “other” party, the subscription clause of the 1672 Act, and J. H. Stevenson (1896, 1927), for whom “the mere territorial baron has no title of dignity appropriated to him”.
“…a Barony, as we call it, do ennoble; for Baronies are establisht only by the Prince’s Erection or Confirmation.”
Today, a holder of a barony within the Baronage of Scotland is a member of Scotland’s titled nobility, though not a peer. The distinction matters: the Scottish equivalent of an English peerage baron is the higher title Lord of Parliament (the lowest rank of the Scottish Peerage, which ranks in order of Lord of Parliament, Viscount, Earl, Marquis, Duke). A Scottish baron is noble but sits below the peerage. The prefix “The Much Honoured” is the honorific traditionally used to distinguish a Scottish baron from a peer.
Scotland followed France and much of continental Europe, recognising both peerage and non-peerage titled nobility — the Scottish baron belongs to the latter. Scots nobiliary practice followed continental custom in this, which is why a barony can be a genuine title of nobility without being a peerage. Baronies were affirmed in Lord Clyde’s 1992 dictum as heritable titles of honour.
Authority: Court of the Lord Lyon, interlocutor of 26 February 1943 (Lord Lyon Sir Francis Grant) in a petition for a birthbrief, recorded in the Public Register of All Genealogies and Birthbrieves, vol. iv, p. 26; printed in Innes of Learney, PSAS vol. 79 (1944–45), p. 143 n. 3: “the Minor Barons of Scotland are, and have been both in this nobiliary Court and in the Court of Session recognised as a ‘titled nobility’…” Innes of Learney on the Act of 1567 (same paper, p. 132): “This clarifies the (obvious) nobiliary fact, that the Barons are a part of ‘The Nobility’ in its constitutional sense, and as an ‘Order’ or ‘Estate’”. Lord Lyon David Sellar, 2010 [Ref: 57 Lindberg Ptr, Lyon Court]: “the dignity of baron has a noble character in that it is a right which historically originated in a Crown grant.”Spencer-Thomas of Buquhollie v Newell (1992), Lord Clyde’s dictum: “a barony falls into the class of noble as opposed to ignoble feus… It was at the earliest a territorial dignity as distinct from the later personal peerage.” Sir Robert Douglas, The Baronage of Scotland (1798), p. 1, a foundational text on Scottish nobility: “There is no nation in Europe where the Gentry, or lesser Barons and Freeholders, enjoyed so much liberty, or had such extensive privileges as those of Scotland.” On the history of the word: Innes of Learney, “The Robes of the Feudal Baronage of Scotland”, PSAS 79 (1944–45), pp. 113 (Spynie), 142, 144, 157–161 (suit-rolls, Kilravock, Cambo); Sir George Mackenzie, Works vol. ii (Science of Herauldry, 1680), pp. 549–550; RPS 1672/6/57 (Lyon King at Arms Act, subscription clause); Lord Lyon Sellar, Note in Sturzenegger of Arran, p. 8 (Stevenson).
Authority & sources. Court of the Lord Lyon, interlocutor of 26 February 1943 (Lord Lyon Sir Francis Grant) in a petition for a birthbrief, recorded in the Public Register of All Genealogies and Birthbrieves, vol. iv, p. 26; printed in Innes of Learney, PSAS vol. 79 (1944–45), p. 143 n. 3: “the Minor Barons of Scotland are, and have been both in this nobiliary Court and in the Court of Session recognised as a ‘titled nobility’…” Innes of Learney on the Act of 1567 (same paper, p. 132): “This clarifies the (obvious) nobiliary fact, that the Barons are a part of ‘The Nobility’ in its constitutional sense, and as an ‘Order’ or ‘Estate’”. Lord Lyon David Sellar, 2010 [Ref: 57 Lindberg Ptr, Lyon Court]: “the dignity of baron has a noble character in that it is a right which historically originated in a Crown grant.”Spencer-Thomas of Buquhollie v Newell (1992), Lord Clyde’s dictum: “a barony falls into the class of noble as opposed to ignoble feus… It was at the earliest a territorial dignity as distinct from the later personal peerage.” Sir Robert Douglas, The Baronage of Scotland (1798), p. 1, a foundational text on Scottish nobility: “There is no nation in Europe where the Gentry, or lesser Barons and Freeholders, enjoyed so much liberty, or had such extensive privileges as those of Scotland.” On the history of the word: Innes of Learney, “The Robes of the Feudal Baronage of Scotland”, PSAS 79 (1944–45), pp. 113 (Spynie), 142, 144, 157–161 (suit-rolls, Kilravock, Cambo); Sir George Mackenzie, Works vol. ii (Science of Herauldry, 1680), pp. 549–550; RPS 1672/6/57 (Lyon King at Arms Act, subscription clause); Lord Lyon Sellar, Note in Sturzenegger of Arran, p. 8 (Stevenson).
Is “Scottish feudal barony” or “feudal baron” or “feudal title” the correct term today?
No longer. Until 2004 these were properly called feudal baronies, because the dignity was attached to land held of the Crown. The Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000, which came into force on 28 November 2004, ended the feudal system and severed the dignity from the land. Extant baronies were expressly preserved, but the feudal aspects and the word “feudal” are now dated as a descriptor of a living barony — the titles were retained specifically as personal, non-territorial dignities. In the words of the Act (s. 63): “an estate held in barony ceases to exist as a feudal estate, the dignity of baron, though retained, shall not attach to the land” — and “nothing in this Act affects the dignity of baron”. In plain terms: this was the abolition of the feudal barony, retaining the dignity of baron — so the “feudal baron” is now incorrect: a defunct historical term with no meaning in law.
The term lingers — other organisations can still be found writing “feudal barony” from habit — but legacy usage does not revive a legal category the 2000 Act closed. In law there is no such thing as a feudal baron today: since 28 November 2004 there has been no feudal tenure in Scotland for a barony to be feudal of — the feudal barony itself was extinguished, leaving only the title of baron, without the word “feudal”. The statute, not custom, settles the terminology.
Lord Lyon Sellar, in 2009, accordingly termed them “quondam feudal baronies” — quondam meaning “formerly”. The historically precise usage is thus “quondam feudal” for the pre-2004 character of a barony, and simply “barony” or “personal dignity” for its present one. For the titleholder, baron or lord or earl in the Baronage of Scotland is the correct modern description; collectively, the minor barons of Scotland, the term used by the Court of the Lord Lyon for this rank of the ancient nobility.
The Scottish Law Commission’s 1999 report that led to the Act drew the same line: the Scottish Parliament could “abolish feudal baronies altogether” while allowing “the dignity of baron, derived from the former connection with the Crown as feudal superior, to continue as a floating dignity” (p. 24); its discussion paper had mentioned, but rejected, the possibility of allowing the “noble aspects of the barony title” to lapse along with the abolition of the feudal relationship (para. 2.34). The feudal framework was abolished; the noble dignity continues. The abolition itself, with the Act, the Explanatory Notes and the Law Commission quoted, is set out on the Index of Scottish Baronies.
Authority: Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000, s.63 — nothing in the Act affects “the dignity of baron or any other dignity or office”; commenced 28 November 2004. Lord Lyon W. D. H. Sellar (2009), p. 82, quoted in Donald Draper Campbell, Scottish Armory and Heraldry (2019). Scottish Law Commission, Report on Abolition of the Feudal System (Scot Law Com No 168, 1999), p. 24 and para. 2.34. Explanatory Notes to the 2000 Act, paras 197–198: “Subsection (1) expressly preserves the dignity of baron”; “the retained dignity of baron will no longer attach to the land. It will be a floating dignity”.
Authority & sources. Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000, s.63 — nothing in the Act affects “the dignity of baron or any other dignity or office”; commenced 28 November 2004. Lord Lyon W. D. H. Sellar (2009), p. 82, quoted in Donald Draper Campbell, Scottish Armory and Heraldry (2019). Scottish Law Commission, Report on Abolition of the Feudal System (Scot Law Com No 168, 1999), p. 24 and para. 2.34. Explanatory Notes to the 2000 Act, paras 197–198: “Subsection (1) expressly preserves the dignity of baron”; “the retained dignity of baron will no longer attach to the land. It will be a floating dignity”.
Can a Scottish barony be bought and sold?
This is widely misunderstood in both directions. Technically, in law, yes: since the 2004 reform baronies are freely transferable dignities and may pass by inheritance, bequest, gift, or assignation, with the transferee becoming the new holder.
A note from this site: Baronies pledged on the Roll of Scottish Barons are treated by the Roll as hereditary and not in commercio. A growing number of barons wish to reduce the in commercio aspect of baronies. By signing The Pledge they commit their title to hereditary descent — a commitment that shapes the future recognition of the barony upon the Roll of Scottish Barons, as explained in the next question.
In practice, the market is very small. The Scottish Barony Register (see how the SBR and the Roll differ) publishes annual reports of the Custodian (publicly available for 2021–2025); these record a handful of transfers in a typical year — and a recorded transfer is not necessarily a commercial sale, since assignations within families and by bequest can sometimes pass through the same register. Baronies generally remain within families across generations; a barony can only be bought if a holder chooses to part with one, and few do. Families are not selling their heirlooms.
Authority: Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000 (transferability); Succession (Scotland) Act 1964 (intestate descent). Transfer volume: Annual Reports of the Custodian, Scottish Barony Register, 2021–2025. The prevalence of family retention over sale is a market observation, not a rule of law.
Authority & sources. Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000 (transferability); Succession (Scotland) Act 1964 (intestate descent). Transfer volume: Annual Reports of the Custodian, Scottish Barony Register, 2021–2025. The prevalence of family retention over sale is a market observation, not a rule of law.
What is The Pledge, and what does it change?
Baronies pledged on the Roll of Scottish Barons are treated by the Roll as hereditary and not in commercio. The Pledge is a declaration of honour by which a baron commits their barony to hereditary descent within the family line. It is open to every holder, inherited or not, and is meant to be re-signed by future heirs; it is optional. A growing number of barons have taken it, wishing to reduce the in commercio transfer of baronies. It cannot legally alter a barony — it operates in honour rather than law — but its practical effect is on future recognition upon the Roll of Scottish Barons, should a pledged barony later be sold outside the family.
In separating recognition from legal title, the Roll follows the model of the two official Rolls. The instructive recent example is the former Prince Andrew: Andrew Mountbatten Windsor remains Duke of York in law — only an Act of Parliament can extinguish a peerage — yet the King’s removal of his name from the Roll of the Peerage in 2025 withdrew official recognition of the title, not his legal entitlement to it. The Roll of the Baronetage goes a degree further: no one is received or styled as a baronet unless entered upon it.
The Roll of Scottish Barons is modelled between the two: recognition upon the Roll is paramount, as with the baronetage, while legal title is never affected, as with the peerage. A pledged barony that is later sold out of the family line does not cease to exist in law — but its recognition on the Roll is a matter of the Roll’s published method, just as the peerage and baronetage Rolls govern recognition in their own spheres. See The Roll for how the two official Rolls work.
Authority: The Pledge (a convention of honour, not statute — it cannot alter a barony in law). Roll of the Peerage: created by royal warrant, 1 June 2004; maintained by the Crown Office and published by the College of Arms; the removal of Andrew Mountbatten Windsor from it in 2025 was widely reported, the dukedom itself remaining extant in law. Roll of the Baronetage: royal warrant of Edward VII, 1910 — precedence and official styling as a baronet follow enrolment.
Authority & sources. The Pledge (a convention of honour, not statute — it cannot alter a barony in law). Roll of the Peerage: created by royal warrant, 1 June 2004; maintained by the Crown Office and published by the College of Arms; the removal of Andrew Mountbatten Windsor from it in 2025 was widely reported, the dukedom itself remaining extant in law. Roll of the Baronetage: royal warrant of Edward VII, 1910 — precedence and official styling as a baronet follow enrolment.
How does succession to a barony work?
Scottish titles have historically had more liberal succession rules than their English counterparts, with some descending through female lines. The earliest baronies, like other early dignities, carried remainders to “heirs and assignees” — because all noble titles, including the higher dignities that became today’s peerage, were originally territorial: they ran with the owner of the estate rather than the person. However, the title and estate were typically entailed to the male heir, which kept them in the family line for hundreds of years. Over time territorial peerages evolved into personal peerages attached to the individual.
Before the Union, Scotland operated differently from England. Titles were designed to be perpetual and were often resigned to the Crown and reissued with a new destination — for instance to a kinsman or a member of the clan — giving the system a flexibility the English peerage lacked. When a barony passed to a new family or baron, the practice was to resign the title and obtain reconfirmation of the feudal grant from the Crown. The Conveyancing (Scotland) Act 1874 ended this practice, and Crown confirmation charters ceased; thereafter it was assignation by legal conveyance and registration in the Register of Sasines that established the new baron. This is what created the so-called feudal earl.
Since 2004 the system has changed once more. The barony is now an incorporeal hereditament — a non-territorial personal dignity — which nonetheless retains the old remainder to heirs and assignees. It can be transferred or bequeathed by will, and where a holder dies without settling it, it descends under the pre-1964 rules preserved for titles and dignities.
Authority: Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000, s.63(2) and Explanatory Notes para. 198; Succession (Scotland) Act 1964 (which preserved the pre-1964 rules of descent for titles and dignities); Conveyancing (Scotland) Act 1874.
Authority & sources. Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000, s.63(2) and Explanatory Notes para. 198; Succession (Scotland) Act 1964 (which preserved the pre-1964 rules of descent for titles and dignities); Conveyancing (Scotland) Act 1874.
What did the 2004 change actually do?
It converted baronies from territorial dignities into personal ones. Before 2004 a barony was tied to a defined estate and its caput (the head place of the barony). After 2004 the dignity “floats” free of any land: it is an incorporeal dignity, comparable in legal status to a hereditary peerage, baronetcy, or coat of arms, but conferring no right to land.
It is sometimes said that since 2004 a barony confers no status or legal privilege. The Act says otherwise: section 63(4) preserves the dignity’s “quality or precedence” and its “heraldic privilege”, and the Lyon Court has continued to act on both.
Authority: Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000, s.63(2), and its Explanatory Notes, para. 198 — the retained dignity “will be a floating dignity” no longer attaching to land, becoming a non-territorial dignity. Scottish Law Commission, Report on Abolition of the Feudal System (Scot Law Com No 168, 1999).
Authority & sources. Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000, s.63(2), and its Explanatory Notes, para. 198 — the retained dignity “will be a floating dignity” no longer attaching to land, becoming a non-territorial dignity. Scottish Law Commission, Report on Abolition of the Feudal System (Scot Law Com No 168, 1999).
The Explanatory Notes to the Act confirm that the dignity survives as a personal, non-territorial “floating” dignity, no longer attached to land. A Scottish barony is therefore a recognised dignity in Scots law, held independently of any estate.
Authority & sources. Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000, s.63 and its Explanatory Notes — legislation.gov.uk. Section 63(4): “‘dignity’ includes any quality or precedence associated with, and any heraldic privilege incidental to, a dignity”. Lord Lyon Morrow, Note in the petition of Menking (30 April 2015), paras 6–8 — ownership of a barony brings the petitioner within the jurisdiction of the Lord Lyon.
Are Scottish barony titles legitimate, or a scam?
They are legitimate. A Scottish barony is a genuine dignity and honour recognised in Scots law: the barons of Scotland were affirmed as a “titled nobility” by the Court of the Lord Lyon in 1943 and by the Court of Session, and section 63 of the Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc. (Scotland) Act 2000 expressly preserved the dignity of baron when the feudal system was abolished.
What is not a title is a “souvenir plot” — a novelty square of Scottish land sold online with a “Lord” or “Laird” label. Owning one confers no title and no nobility; the Court of the Lord Lyon states that a souvenir plot is not even sufficient to petition for a grant of arms. Nearly every “Scottish title scam” story concerns these souvenir schemes — not genuine baronies, which are an entirely different thing (see Can you buy a “Lord” or “Laird” title in Scotland?).
Can you buy a “Lord” or “Laird” title in Scotland?
A souvenir plot does not make you a Lord or a Laird — this is a widespread misunderstanding. Owning a novelty square of Scottish land confers no title: the Court of the Lord Lyon states that “laird” is “a description rather than a title”, and that a souvenir plot is not sufficient to bring a person within the Lyon Court’s jurisdiction to seek a grant of arms. On what “laird” and “lord” have meant in Scotland, see Lairds, lords and barons.
More broadly, it is a common myth that one can simply buy one’s way into the genuine nobility of the United Kingdom. The Honours (Prevention of Abuses) Act 1925 makes it a criminal offence to trade in the grant of honours.
What is a territorial designation (TD), and is it the same as a barony?
No — a territorial designation is not the same as a barony, and the two are often confused. A barony is a title of nobility. The distinctly Scottish territorial designation “Surname of Place” form, such as “Kerr of Ardgowan” — is part of a person’s family name, not a title of nobility. The two are separate, and may or may not coincide. Where they did, the records call the same baron by both, the title and the name, often in the same deed: see Baron of X, or X of Y? Two styles of a Scottish baron
A baron may use the barony title (for example “Baron of X”) as a matter of legal right, without the Lord Lyon’s permission: the Explanatory Notes to section 63 of the 2000 Act say that the holder “has the right to use the title of baron” and that ownership “enables the owner to adopt the title of ‘Baron of …’” (paras 195–196) — although the Lord Lyon’s recognition of the barony title in the holder’s favour is nonetheless helpful (see Will the Lord Lyon recognise a baron as a baron?). A territorial designation is different: to be on the official record it must be authorised by the Court of the Lord Lyon, and is recognised only where the applicant owns a substantial estate — in Lord Lyon Sellar’s guidance of 5 January 2010, “an ‘estate’, or farm or, at the very least, a house with policies extending to five acres or thereby, outwith a burgh”. In the Kerr of Ardgowan case the petitioner was recognised as Baron of Ardgowan, yet the matching territorial designation was treated as a separate question — the Court of Session confirming the Lord Lyon’s discretion to grant or refuse a territorial designation. In Kerr of Ardgowan v Lord Lyon 2009 SLT 759 the Extra Division held that the Lord Lyon “does indeed enjoy a wide discretion in deciding whether or not to accept a change of name for entry in the Public Register”. That discretion is over the official record, not over what a person may call himself: in the same case the court said that the petitioners “can call themselves by any name they choose” (para. [11]), official recognition in the Public Register being a different matter.
A territorial designation becomes a heritable part of the surname, separable from the land, only after it has been held and used for three generations, or 82 years. And owning the caput — the head place of a barony — does not by itself entitle the holder to the matching designation; that too must be authorised by the Lord Lyon.
In practice, many barons hold no territorial designation, and most people who hold a territorial designation are not barons; the two can be the same, different, or unconnected. A territorial designation belongs to the family name (surname), not to a barony or peerage title. TDs belong mainly to lairds (landowners of historic estates) and long-established landed families.
A baron may hold one too: where he owns the lands historically associated with his barony and is so recognised by the Lord Lyon, he may be “Surname of [TD]” as well as “Baron of [Barony]” — though the designation and the barony remain distinct.
A handful of Scottish peers also carry a territorial designation in their surname. The Rt Hon Jean Drummond of Megginch, 16th Baroness Strange (d. 2005), famously had the designation “of Megginch” recognised by the Lord Lyon in her surname — separately from her peerage Strange, which carries no territorial element. The Rt Hon James Borthwick of that Ilk, 25th Lord Borthwick, and The Rt Hon Patrick Johnstone of Annandale and of that Ilk, 11th Earl of Annandale and Hartfell, are others. This is different again from a peerage that merely includes a place-name: The Rt Hon Donald Cameron of Lochiel, Lord Cameron of Lochiel — “Lord Cameron of Lochiel” is a peerage title, distinct from his surname, “Cameron of Lochiel”, which carries the territorial designation.
“Of that Ilk” is a form of territorial designation used where the surname and the place are one and the same. “Borthwick of that Ilk” and “Borthwick of Borthwick” mean the same thing; which form is used is a matter of preference.
The custom has a statutory root. The Lyon King of Arms Act 1672 allowed only peers and bishops to subscribe by their titles, while “all others shall subscribe their christened names … with their surnames, and may, if they please, adject the designations of their lands prefixing the word ‘of’ to the said designations”. The clause was repealed as spent by the Requirements of Writing (Scotland) Act 1995, but it is the origin of the territorial “of”.
The usage is continental in character: the Scots “of” before a placename does the work of the Continent’s nobiliary particles — the German von, the French and Spanish de — naming a family after its territory. It is a custom Scotland shares with Europe, in keeping with the rest of its nobiliary practice. The territorial “of” does not exist in the United Kingdom outside Scotland: UK institutions such as HM Passport Office and the College of Arms refer “of” surnames to the Lord Lyon, and an “of” surname marks its bearer as Scottish. For the history of the designation — the 1672 Act, the Lyon Court’s test, and the passport — see Lairds, lords and barons in the Reading Room.
Maybe — this is at the discretion of the sitting Lord Lyon. Traditionally, in a petition for a grant of arms, where the Lord Lyon determines that the dignity of baron exists, that the petitioner is a “virtuous and well deserving person” — the standard set by the Lyon King of Arms Act 1672 — and exercises his discretion in the petitioner’s favour, he will officially recognise the petitioner as “Baron of [the barony]” and grant arms with additaments and a helmet befitting their degree. In recent years, the Lord Lyon routinely treats an entry in the Scottish Barony Register as sufficient evidence that the dignity exists, and may grant arms without recognition.
Recognition is not what makes a baron a baron — the dignity is held as of legal right. But recognition by the Lord Lyon is the formal mark of the title within Scotland’s heraldic system, and it rests with the judgement of each sitting Lord Lyon. The Lord Lyon holds considerable autonomy in this respect: part of that discretion is that the form of address recorded on the grant of arms is the one that should be used for official purposes.
The dignity itself is held as of right under s. 63 of the 2000 Act. In Hamilton of Rockhall v Lord Lyon [2019] CSOH 85 the Court of Session said a grant of arms is “only ever a matter of grace (and not entitlement)”. That was said of arms, not of the title. The court did not decide whether a baron is entitled to be recognised as a baron. The Lord Lyon has also said that “in Scotland anyone is at liberty to call themselves what they wish subject to it not being the intention to deceive” (Menking, Note of 30 April 2015, para 21).
No Lord Lyon binds the next. In Hamilton of Rockhall the Court of Session held that no policy or practice of a Lord Lyon is “capable of binding successors in the office of Lord Lyon in the grant of arms” (para 86), and the Lyon Court’s own counsel put it plainly: “no Lord Lyon is bound to follow a policy of his predecessor, for none can bind his successor” (para 39).
Authority: Lyon King of Arms Act 1672 — grants of arms to “virtuous and well deserving persons”; the Lord Lyon’s published policy on baronies acquired after 28 November 2004 — official recognition as “Baron of [the barony]” where the dignity is proven and the discretion is exercised in the petitioner’s favour; Court of the Lord Lyon. Hamilton of Rockhall v Lord Lyon King of Arms [2019] CSOH 85 (Court of Session, Outer House), paras [39], [84], [86] and [91] — a grant of arms is “only ever a matter of grace (and not entitlement)”; the court did not decide whether a baron is entitled to recognition of the title; no policy of a Lord Lyon binds his successor in office. Lord Lyon Morrow, Note in the petition of Menking (30 April 2015), para 21.
Authority & sources. Lyon King of Arms Act 1672 — grants of arms to “virtuous and well deserving persons”; the Lord Lyon’s published policy on baronies acquired after 28 November 2004 — official recognition as “Baron of [the barony]” where the dignity is proven and the discretion is exercised in the petitioner’s favour; Court of the Lord Lyon. Hamilton of Rockhall v Lord Lyon King of Arms [2019] CSOH 85 (Court of Session, Outer House), paras [39], [84], [86] and [91] — a grant of arms is “only ever a matter of grace (and not entitlement)”; the court did not decide whether a baron is entitled to recognition of the title; no policy of a Lord Lyon binds his successor in office. Lord Lyon Morrow, Note in the petition of Menking (30 April 2015), para 21.
What is the difference between a barony and a Lordship of the Manor?
They are entirely different things and are often confused, sometimes deliberately. A Scottish barony is a title of nobility, granted historically by the Crown through a charter, conferring precedence, privileges, and — until the Union of 1707 — a place among the ancient Three Estates of the Scottish Parliament. An English “Lordship of the Manor” was never a Crown-granted title of nobility: it is a style attached to the ownership of a manor and confers no noble rank and no parliamentary rights. The nearest Scottish equivalent to a Lord of the Manor is a Laird. The Court of the Lord Lyon has itself stated that “laird” is “a description rather than a title”, and it likewise carries no formal status in law. For what the words themselves have meant, see Lairds, lords and barons.
The claim, made by some, that Scottish baronies are simply the Scottish name for English manors is incorrect: the two arise from different legal systems and carry different status. Today a barony retains legal standing as a personal dignity and carries heraldic rights; a Lordship of the Manor does not, because it never conferred noble rank in the first place.
Authority: Spencer-Thomas of Buquhollie v Newell (Court of Session — the noble quality of the barony grant); historical accounts of the Scottish Three Estates. On Laird: Court of the Lord Lyon, “Lairds”, archived 2012 — “the term ‘laird’ … is a description rather than a title”.
Authority & sources. Spencer-Thomas of Buquhollie v Newell (Court of Session — the noble quality of the barony grant); historical accounts of the Scottish Three Estates. On Laird: Court of the Lord Lyon, “Lairds”, archived 2012 — “the term ‘laird’ … is a description rather than a title”.
How does a Scottish barony differ from an English or Irish feudal barony?
There are no recognised English or Irish feudal barons today. They developed along different lines. Scotland followed the continental pattern of a titled nobility that extends below the peerage — a class of noble barons, with the territorial “of” that answers to the German von or the French de. In England and Ireland the word “baron” went the other way and became the lowest rank of the peerage; there is no English or Irish equivalent of the Scottish non-peerage titled baron. (The Scottish peerage has its own lowest rank, the Lord of Parliament, discussed above.)
The earliest English baronies were baronies by tenure — held per baroniam, directly of the Crown, the tenure itself carrying a duty to attend Parliament. From the thirteenth century the summons came instead by writ (a barony by writ). The Tenures Abolition Act 1660 then swept away the old feudal tenures: many baronies by tenure were converted into baronies by writ, and the rest ceased to exist as recognised feudal baronies, their lands passing into free socage. The courts closed the door on the older form — the Fitzwalter case (1670) held that barony by tenure had long been discontinued, and the Berkeley case (1861) confirmed that baronies by tenure no longer existed.
In Ireland the picture is more tangled still. An Irish feudal barony was a customary title denoting land held by feudal obligation rather than a rank of nobility, and its holder sat in no parliament by right of it. Separately — and more commonly — “barony” in Ireland means an administrative division of a county, akin to an English hundred, which is not a title at all; spurious “titles” have been sold trading on those place-names.
The Scottish barony followed neither path. Neither a peerage nor a mere tenure, but a dignity of a titled nobility, it came through the abolition of the feudal system in 2004 expressly preserved as a personal, non-territorial dignity — as set out above.
Lord Lyon Sellar put it thus in Sturzenegger of Arran: “Anachronistic and anomalous the position of the former feudal baron may be, but there can be no doubt about the thread of continuity from the earliest days of feudalism in Scotland until the present day.” And on the Heritable Jurisdictions Act, often assumed to have ended the Scottish barony: “Baron courts, however, were not abolished by the Heritable Jurisdictions Act, although their jurisdiction, both civil and criminal, was greatly reduced. … The style of ‘Baron’, although not incorrect, gradually fell into desuetude.”
Authority: Tenures Abolition Act 1660 (conversion of feudal tenures to socage); Fitzwalter case (1670) and the Berkeley Peerage case (1861), Committee for Privileges of the House of Lords — barony by tenure obsolete. On Ireland, the distinction between an Irish feudal barony and an administrative barony (a land division of a county). Lord Lyon Sellar, Note in the petition of Sturzenegger of Arran, pp. 7, 10–11 — the “thread of continuity” and the effect of the Heritable Jurisdictions Act on baron courts.
Authority & sources. Tenures Abolition Act 1660 (conversion of feudal tenures to socage); Fitzwalter case (1670) and the Berkeley Peerage case (1861), Committee for Privileges of the House of Lords — barony by tenure obsolete. On Ireland, the distinction between an Irish feudal barony and an administrative barony (a land division of a county). Lord Lyon Sellar, Note in the petition of Sturzenegger of Arran, pp. 7, 10–11 — the “thread of continuity” and the effect of the Heritable Jurisdictions Act on baron courts.
What is the difference between the Scottish Barony Register and the Roll?
The Scottish Barony Register (SBR) and the Roll of Scottish Barons are often confused, but they do different jobs: one records legal transfers, the other recognises the title. Set side by side, here is what each records, and what it does not:
Authority: Scottish Barony Register — scottishbaronyregister.org . See also The Roll for the Roll’s own account of related organisations, including the SBR, and the Roll’s inclusion criteria.
Authority & sources. Scottish Barony Register — scottishbaronyregister.org . See also The Roll for the Roll’s own account of related organisations, including the SBR, and the Roll’s inclusion criteria.
Glossary of terms
Scottish feudal barony
A now incorrect and defunct historical term. Baronies were feudal until 28 November 2004, when the feudal system was abolished along with all feudal aspects; extant baronies continue as personal, non-territorial dignities, so a living barony is no longer “feudal”. The precise term for the historic character is “quondam” (formerly) feudal barony.
Quondam feudal barony
A barony that was feudal before 28 November 2004. “Quondam” means “formerly”; the phrase (Lord Lyon Sellar, 2009) marks that a barony's feudal character is now historical, the living dignity personal and non-territorial.
Scottish barony
A dignity which can be baron or lord or earl in the Baronage of Scotland — a title of nobility ranking below the peerage. Historically attached to land held of the Crown, it has, since the 2004 reform, been a personal, non-territorial dignity. Its holder is a baron, or “minor baron” — noble, but not a peer.
Minor baron
A holder of a Scottish barony — a member of Scotland's titled nobility ranking below the peerage. The term used by the Court of the Lord Lyon to distinguish these barons from barons of the peerage.
Greater and lesser barons. The greater barons became the peerage; the lesser — the “small barons” of the Acts — are the Baronage of Scotland. Under the robes Act of 1455 minor barons (who were always members of parliament but later not obligated to attend) and Lords of Parliament were not told apart by dress: Barons and Lords of Parliament both wore the same red mantle, open at the front and lined with silk or furred with grey. The higher ranks were marked apart by mantles of their own — the earls, under the same Act, in ‘grained’ brown furred with white, and in later usage dukes, marquesses and earls graded by the rows of ermine on their robes. In 1567 Parliament declared the barons “a part of the nobility”. Craig: “Dukes, marquesses, and earls are all comprehended among the barons, and originally they were all known under the latter description.”
RPS 1455/8/12 (robes); RPS 1567/12/45 (“a part of the nobility”); Craig, Jus Feudale, I.12.15; Innes of Learney, PSAS 79, pp. 124–148 (the robes).
Constitutional baron
A baron by the law and constitution of Scotland: the barons formed an estate of Parliament (Act of 1567: “the barons of this realm ought to have vote in Parliament as a part of the nobility”), and were recognised by Crown, Parliament and the Lyon Court by the style “Baron of X”. The Esslemont Memorial of 1934, upheld by Lord Lyon Grant and printed by Innes of Learney in 1945, called them “truly constitutional barons”, as against barons created by patent under the English peerage and the “much inferior baronages of the Continent”.
The Scots word for lord: a description and courtesy, not a title, like “landlord” or “lord of the manor” in England. It is a catch-all term — the neighbours call you laird whether you are a baron or not. In medieval England, likewise, every master of an estate was called a lord; the distinction developed differently in Scotland, with Lord being a word for a titled noble which were predominantly peers but also crown chartered lords without a greater title (a minor baron holding the higher rank of lord in the baronage of Scotland). Lairds if they hold a coat of arms but are not barons are untitled nobility (gentry in the English sense).
A laird who was not a baron: a vassal holding land directly of the Crown without a grant in free barony. Freeholders and small barons (both commonly referred to as lairds) were excused attendance at Parliament together in 1428. Until then both owed suit and presence in Parliament as members and were liable to fines for absence, so for the minor barons — who bore the burden and expense of travelling to wherever Parliament sat — the Act came as a relief rather than a loss. From 1587 they voted together for shire commissioners (on forty shillings of land held of the king). But “Freeholders were not Barons and everybody recognised that”; heraldically they had no baronial insignia.
An intangible heritable right that may be held and inherited without attaching to land. Since 2004 a Scottish barony exists as such a dignity, independent of any estate.
Caput
The head place of a barony — its principal seat or centre, from which the barony took its name and, historically, where the baron's court was held.
Peerage
The highest grade of the British nobility. In Scotland its ranks, in ascending order, are Lord of Parliament, Viscount, Earl, Marquess and Duke in the peerage of Scotland. A peerage stands in law whether or not its holder is enrolled, and historically carried a seat in Parliament. It ranks above, and is distinct from, a barony in the Baronage of Scotland. In sixteenth-century usage the Peerage was, in Innes of Learney’s words, what “on English terminology got loosely called ‘the Nobility’”, while Parliament in 1567 acknowledged the Baronage as “a part of the nobility”; the Lyon King of Arms Acts of 1592 and 1672 use “noblemen” in that narrower sense, so “noblemen, barons and gentlemen” means peers, barons and gentlemen (PSAS 79, p. 136).
The lowest rank of the Scottish peerage, below Viscount, Earl, Marquess and Duke in the peerage of Scotland — the Scottish equivalent of an English peerage baron, and a higher dignity than a (minor) baron. Lords of Parliament arose in the mid-15th century from among the greater barons — territorial dignities at that stage, the term “peerage” itself settling into use only closer to the Union of 1707. The lesser barons (minor barons) also sat among the nobility in Parliament in their own right: from 1428 they were relieved of the obligation to attend in person, due to the expense and burdens of travel, and an Act of 1587 allowed them to be represented by elected commissioners for the shires, though minor barons retained the legal right to attend in person — which continued until the Union of 1707.
Baronetcy
A hereditary knighthood ranking below the peerage and above a knighthood. A baronet is styled “Sir” (or “Dame”), and the dignity passes to heirs — unlike a knighthood, which is personal.
Knighthood
A personal, non-hereditary honour conferring the style “Sir” (or “Dame”). Unlike a peerage, a barony or a baronetcy, it does not pass to the holder's heirs.
Esquire
The upper gentry without a title, ranking between knights and the plain gentlemen: men of gentle birth, or major landowners. Historically linked to lineage (the eldest sons of knights, the younger sons of peers), royal grant or office (such as justice of the peace). Written “Esq.” after the name: John Smith, Esq.
Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England, vol. I (1765), pp. 393–394, following Camden: the eldest sons of knights and the younger sons of peers, with their eldest sons after them; esquires made by the king’s letters patent; and those who hold an office of trust under the Crown. Sir Thomas Smith, De Republica Anglorum (1583), ch. 19, p. 37 (esquires are those of the gentlemen who bear arms, the marks of their family). In Scotland the barons rank “after Knights and before Esquires” (Innes of Learney, PSAS 79, p. 113), and an esquire who bears arms is of the untitled nobility: see Nobility clause. “Esq.” and “Gent.” are the “addition” of a man’s degree after his name, required in legal proceedings by the statute 1 Hen. V c. 5 (1413): Blackstone, p. 394. On gentle birth, see Gentleman.
Gentleman
The rank below esquire: a man of gentle birth, one of those “whom their blood and race doth make noble and known” (Sir Thomas Smith, 1583), defined by an ancestral right to bear arms, a genteel lifestyle and manners, and freedom from manual labour. Written “Gent.” after the name. In Scotland a gentleman who bears arms is of the untitled nobility.
Smith, De Republica Anglorum (1583), ch. 20, pp. 38–40: gentlemen are those “whom their blood and race doth make noble and known”, and whoever “can live idly, and without manual labour, and will bear the port, charge, and countenance of a gentleman, he shall be called master, and shall be taken for a gentleman”, in Blackstone’s quotation, Commentaries, vol. I (1765), pp. 393–394, where a gentleman is, after Coke, one “who bears coat armour”. “Gent.”: see Esquire. In Scotland: see Nobility clause. Gentle birth in the Lyon Court’s words: in 1930 it certified a family “of the rank of minor barons or untitled nobility of Scotland” to be “of gentle blood, knightly descent, ancient lineage”: see the paper Untitled or titled nobility?
Chief
The head of a clan or family. Since at least the 16th century a chief has had to be entitled to bear the undifferenced arms of the clan or family, and so be “Chief of the Name and Arms”; it is for the Lord Lyon to decide who has succeeded. A chief so recognised “is chief of all who bear the name of the clan or family”, not only of the members of a clan society.
Scotland's public register of land deeds. After the Conveyancing (Scotland) Act 1874 the transfer of a barony was recorded here; since 2004, baronies are recorded in the separate Scottish Barony Register.
Territorial designation (TD)
A “Surname of Place” designation — such as “Kerr of Ardgowan” — that forms part of a person's name. TDs are governed by the Court of the Lord Lyon and generally require ownership of a substantial estate. It is not a title of nobility or dignity, and is separate from a barony, although certainly untitled nobility; a person may hold either, both, or neither. The custom is distinctly Scottish and does not apply to the rest of the British Isles.
A form of territorial designation used where a family's surname and its lands share the same name — “Borthwick of that Ilk” means “Borthwick of Borthwick”. The two forms are interchangeable.
Representer (of a House)
The person recognised by the Lord Lyon as head of a family — normally the heir of line — and so entitled to its undifferenced arms. “Representer of the Baronial House of X” in Lyon Court Letters Patent denotes the head of a family that formerly held the barony of X — in plain terms, a former baron’s house — and not the present holder of the barony, which may have passed with the land to another owner (as in the 2001 matriculation for Kincaid of Kincaid). Innes of Learney, who writes “Representative” (“Representer” is the Lyon Court’s later Scots form), held that such representers remain barons in the Continental sense — of baronial race, equivalent to the Continental baronial houses — though not barons in Scots law, the barony having passed with the land: “such chapeau, once it is matriculated, descends to the ‘heir and representative’ of such ‘baronial race’—who in the Continental sense is of course a ‘Baron’.” He distinguished “heir male” from “representative”, it being from the latter character that the baronial additaments descend.
Innes of Learney, PSAS 79, p. 155 (quoted); p. 154 n. 1 (“‘Heir Male’ is in such terminology a distinct term from ‘Representative’, and it is from the latter character … that baronial exterior additaments descend”); p. 156 (“incorporeally Baronial as the Representatives of Baronial Houses”); p. 142 n. 4. Lord Lyon Sellar, Note in Smith of Craigend.
For aught yet seen
Lyon Court usage for “on the evidence so far”. A recognition “for aught yet seen” is provisional: it stands unless better evidence displaces it. Used since 2009 for barony ownership proved by an entry in the Scottish Barony Register with the Custodian’s report.
Lord Lyon Morrow’s formula (Menking, 2015) for former feudal (territorial) lordships, regalities and earldoms: dignities of the same kind as a barony, whose holders receive a baron’s additaments and are recorded as holding the lordship or earldom.
“Symbols signifying a particular rank” added to a coat of arms (Court of Session, 2019): for barons, the baronial helm; formerly also the chapeau, the feudo-baronial mantle and, for pre-1587 baronies and baronial houses, supporters.
The closing clause of older Lyon Court grants and declarations that the grantee is to be “taken, and received amongst all Nobles and in all places of Honour as Nobles in the Noblesse of Scotland” — the words of the Wauchope of Niddrie declaration of 19 April 1945. A nobility clause was present in Lord Lyon Blair’s grant to the Baron of Ballencrieff (2007); it has been omitted from all Letters Patent for grants made since: for every petitioner, peers included, not for barons alone. According to Innes of Learney: “A [Scottish] coat of arms is the outward indication of [untitled or titled] nobility and arms are officially described as ‘Ensigns of Nobility’. A patent of arms is . . . a Diploma of Nobility. . . .” Clarifying this statement, a later writer on Scottish heraldry has noted: “Technically, a grant of arms from the Lord Lyon is a patent of nobility; the grantee is thereby ‘enrolled with all nobles in the noblesse of Scotland’. This does not constitute a peerage or any title. It is a social distinction, untitled nobility, and has no legal privileges.”
Court of the Lord Lyon (Lord Lyon Sir Francis Grant), 19 April 1945, Lyon Register vol. xxxv p. 31; printed in Innes of Learney, PSAS 79, p. 160 (the words quoted); Hamilton of Rockhall v Lord Lyon [2019] CSOH 85, para [21] (the Ballencrieff grant of 2007; omitted since).
Comes · Dominus · Baro
The Latin rank-words of the sheriff-court rolls — Earl of, Lord of, Baron of — entered as titles (“Intrat A, Baro de B”), corresponding to lands held in free earldom, free lordship and free barony. A “Dominus de X” need not be a Lord of Parliament, but a minor baron holding the higher rank of lord in the baronage of Scotland — interchangeably known as Lord X, Lord of X or Laird of X.
The Continental “high nobility” — houses of baronial rank and above, as opposed to the untitled gentry. Lyon Court declarations of 1938–45 (Chisholm; Wauchope of Niddrie) found Scottish barons “of rank equivalent to that denominated Hoch Adel, and equivalent to the Chiefs of Baronial Houses, upon the Continent of Europe”.
Court of the Lord Lyon (Lord Lyon Sir Francis Grant), 19 April 1945, Lyon Register vol. xxxv p. 31; printed in Innes of Learney, PSAS 79, p. 160 and n. 6.
Scottish Barony Register — Annual Reports of the Custodian , 2021–2025.
Lord Lyon W. D. H. Sellar (2009), “quondam feudal baronies”, quoted in Donald Draper Campbell, Scottish Armory and Heraldry (2019), p. 82.
This page is intended as general education on Scots nobiliary law and does not address the history or succession of any individual title. Readers researching a specific barony should contact us to consult with our genealogist, the relevant charters, and independent genealogical scholarship.
Explore further.
The history of the baronage, the Roll of Scottish Barons, and the correct forms of address.